7 Mistakes to Avoid When Making Soup

7 Mistakes to Avoid When Making Soup

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases

Soup is fairly simple. There are no complicated cooking techniques, so there is no excuse for a bad pot of soup. All that is needed are little care and consideration.

Last week ushered in the first day of fall. Don’t you just love this time of year? The crisp air outside brings us to harvest, football, hayrides, bonfires sweaters, chili, stews, and soups.

Soup season has officially started and there is nothing more comforting than a big ole pot of simmering goodness on the stove or coming home to a crock-pot full ready and waiting. Whether it is simple or complicated, thick or chunky, creamy or spicy, here are 7 mistakes to avoid when making soup this season.

steam bowl of soup with mountain view

7 Mistakes to Avoid When Making Soup:

1. Ignoring the liquid:

The best part of a soul-warming soup is the broth, but if you think you can’t make a delicious soup without it, you’re wrong. It is ok to use water! You are almost better off using water than broth anyway. You may even find you prefer soups made with water. The ingredients are allowed to stand out and aren’t masked by overpowering stocks. Just keep an eye on it and don’t cook all of the water out of it. Keep in mind that as a soup cooks, the broth reduces and some ingredients tend to soak up the broth, such as rice or pasta. It wouldn’t be soup without liquid now, would it? Remember: when in doubt, add more water or stock.

2. Boiling instead of simmering:

Boiling can cause your meat and vegetables to dry out dry and become overcooked. Gently simmering not only cooks the ingredients until they are tender, but also allows the flavors from herbs and spices to infuse the liquid, and the meat and vegetables absorb some of that seasoned liquid while also contributing some of their own flavors back. As the pot simmers, some of the liquid evaporates causing the flavors to become more concentrated and intensify. So go slow!

3. Too much or not using enough salt:

If you add salt at the beginning of cooking you’re almost guaranteed to have salty soup. As I just mentioned, as the soup cooks down, the flavors intensify. You probably won’t need much salt anyway. Remember, have patience and wait until the end to season it. Nothing is as crucial as seasoning correctly. Use a recipe as a guideline, but learn to trust your own taste buds!

4. Overcooking the vegetables:

Try to avoid overcooking vegetables, by adding them according to how much time they need to cook. Regardless of what people think, soup making is a gradual process. For more depth of flavor, add the vegetables that need to cook the longest first. Let them cook a while before adding the vegetables that take the least time to cook.

5. Adding pasta or rice too early:

To me, there is nothing worse than rice or pasta that cannot even hold its shape. Folks, NEVER cook your noodles until they disintegrate! Add these ingredients with just enough time to cook them through according to package directions. Not to mention if you add them in too early, chances are they will stick to the bottom of the pot and scotch ruining your soup!

6. Forgetting about garnishes:

Fresh herbs, freshly cracked pepper, a dusting of Parmesan cheese, or crunchy croutons or crusty bread add another level flavor and texture to a good home-cooked soup. When I make my Spanish-Style White Bean, Kale and Chorizo Soup the flavors are amazingly brought together and given a little zing by adding a splash of red wine vinegar when it is ready to eat. I also loved the paprika brown butter used on the wonderful Roasted Carrot-Apple Soup I made last fall. Other good last-minute garnishes: a dollop of sour cream, chives, lime or lemon juice.

7. You don’t love to make it:

Soup making is a labor of love. If you’re going to rush through it, don’t even bother with trying to make a soup. Soup takes time, patience and passion. Remember this meal is supposed to put a smile on everyone’s face.

bowl of soup with mountain view

Soup needs your care and consideration. I hope by making you aware of these common mistakes will encourage you to make soups that will warm your bones and soothe your soul on a cold day this season.

Looking for soup recipes? Click HERE to visit our recipe index!

The Mountain Kitchen
Follow me
Latest posts by The Mountain Kitchen (see all)

10 thoughts on “7 Mistakes to Avoid When Making Soup”

  • Enjoying experiencing fall in your gorgeous state of Virginia, although the weather is still a little hot and steamy here in Norfolk…maybe a Tom Yum would suit?
    Love making chicken soup (the universal curer of all ills) and find it always taste better the next day.

  • Thanks for this post! I am so bad at making soup, by the time it’s done there is never any broth left ๐Ÿ™ Or I make a large batch to have left overs and the next day all the broth is gone! I found a wild rice and chicken soup recipe I want to make for Thanksgiving but I am so worried I will ruin it ๐Ÿ™

    • Christie,
      I cannot count the number of times I’ve had a thick stew when I wanted a soup. I hope these tips help you out. Don’t be afraid to make mistakes, learn from them! Perhaps you could make a small batch ahead of time to test it out? Good luck with your soup for Turkey Day!
      Thanks so much for commenting & Happy Thanksgiving!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Want FREE Recipes?

Join our mailing list to receive the latest recipes!

Subscription Options

You have Successfully Subscribed!