Pickled Tomatoes Recipe – Quick Pickle

These pickled tomatoes are sweet, tangy, slightly salty, crunchy, and delicious! They are a great condiment, chopped in salads, sliced on sandwiches, or fried. This quick pickled tomatoes recipe is ready in 24 hours!

I’m finding that you can pickle just about anything, even green tomatoes.

Depending on how you want to use them, the green tomatoes are sliced or quartered, then put into a pickling liquid of rice vinegar, sugar, and salt with shallots, sprigs of fresh basil, and jalapeno slices. This quick refrigerator pickle recipe is a small batch ready to enjoy in only 24 hours!

The sweet and tangy yet slightly salty pickled tomatoes are crunchy and delicious. They are the perfect condiments to enjoy as they are, but you can chop them and put them into salads, slice them to put on sandwiches, and you can even fry them!

At the end of last summer, my mama gave me a recipe she found in a Southern Living Magazine for pickled tomatoes. She knows I love fried green tomatoes, so she figured I’d like to try the recipe.

She figured right. I love everything about this recipe.

Let’s pickle some!

What is a Quick Pickle Recipe?

A quick pickle recipe is a pickling recipe that involves a brine mixture, usually consisting of salt, vinegar, and sugar, but does not involve canning. Quick pickles recipes usually only take about 24 hours and are very simple. 

Ingredients & Substitutions For This Pickled Tomatoes Recipe

The recipe card at the end of this post includes a detailed list of ingredients.

For the Brine:

Rice Vinegar: Rice vinegar is one of the most delicate, sweet vinegar you can use. Avoid using seasoned rice vinegar, which generally includes salt, sugar, and sometimes MSG.

Substitutes for Rice Vinegar: 

• Apple Cider Vinegar – sweet, mild taste of apples. Apple cider vinegar is closest in comparison to rice, though it is slightly more robust than rice vinegar.
• Red or White Wine Vinegar – fruity, tangy, somewhat more potent than rice vinegar.
• White Vinegar – although white vinegar is clear like rice vinegar, it tastes the opposite. White vinegar is sour and very harsh. If this is all you have, cut the vinegar back to ½ cup and add 1 ½ cups of water instead of 1 cup.

Sugar: white granulated table sugar. 

Salt: Pickling salt has finer granules than regular table salt, and it does not contain additives which can cause the brine solution to become cloudy. Use kosher salt if you don’t have pickling salt on hand.

For the Pickled Tomatoes:

Green Tomatoes: Green tomatoes have a tart and tangy taste with a crisp, robust texture. Use any green unripened tomato that has not yet turned red and is the size of a baseball or smaller. Various tomatoes, such as Better Boy, Cherry, and Roma tomatoes, are good for pickling.

Fresh Basil: Fresh basil lends the tomatoes a delicate floral and mild licorice flavor. Basil and tomatoes go hand in hand, even when pickled. Only use fresh basil. Try other fresh herbs from your garden, such as parsley and thyme for even more flavor.

Shallots: Shallots have a delicately sweet, fresh flavor when eaten raw. Use sweet onions if you can’t get your hands on shallots. Red onions are also fine, but both will have more onion flavor than the shallot.

Heat:  Jalapenos add a nice spicy heat to balance the sweet and tangy flavor of the brine. Jalapenos can be substituted with ¼ teaspoon of red crushed pepper flakes.

I tested this recipe using both jalapeno slices and red pepper flakes. Although both were very good, David and I agree that the pickled tomatoes with jalapeno slices are better than the red pepper flakes. Not only do the jalapenos provide a mild spice, but they also bring a nice bright flavor to the pickled tomatoes.

If you don’t like spice, remove the veins and seeds from the jalapenos to enjoy the taste without the heat. OR omit the jalapenos or red pepper flakes altogether. 

Salting Green Tomatoes

For best results, salt the green tomatoes before pickling them. Salting the green tomato slices and letting them sit will draw out excess liquid from the tomatoes, which tend to taste bitter. Not only will salting the tomatoes give the green tomatoes a better flavor, but it will also make them crisper and allow them to draw in more of the flavors from the brine solution.

How To Salt Green Tomatoes:

1. Place some tomato slices into the bottom of a bowl in a single layer. Sprinkle the tomatoes lightly with salt. Add another layer of tomatoes on top and sprinkle those lightly with salt. Repeat until all of the tomato slices are salted in the bowl
2. Cover the salted green tomato slices and allow them to sit at room temperature overnight. 
3. Drain the liquid from the tomatoes before pickling. 

Note: Go easy on the salt. If you watch your sodium, you may want to cut back on the salt in the brine solution since the tomato slices are not rinsed.

How to Make Pickled Tomatoes

Salting is optional but recommended!

1. Step #1  Clean the Jar: Wash a 32-ounce wide-mouth canning jar with hot soapy water. Rinse well and allow it to air dry.
2. Step #2  Make the Brine: Combine the ingredients and heat until the sugar and salt dissolve completely.
3. Step #3  Core and Slice the Tomatoes: While the brine is cooling, slice the ends of the tomatoes, removing the core. Cut the tomatoes either into slices, halves, or quarters.
   • Slices are better for topping burgers and sandwiches or even frying.
   • Halves or Quarters are better for chopping to add to dishes or eating alone.
4. Step #4  Pour and Brine: Place the tomato slices, basil, shallots, and jalapenos slices inside the clean canning jar. Pour the cooled brine solution into the jar. Seal tightly and chill for 24 hours. Gently shake the jar every once in a while to ensure the flavors meld well.

After 24 hours, serve as desired. Enjoy pickled tomatoes stored in the fridge for up to 2 months.

Tips For Making This Pickled Tomatoes Recipe

• Size: choose more small tomatoes, no larger than the size of a baseball. Larger tomatoes tend to be more bitter and will not absorb the brine very well. Choose tomatoes slightly smaller than your canning jar’s mouth if making slices.
• Tomato Variety: Use any green unripened tomato that has not yet turned red. Even cherry tomatoes can be used for this recipe.
• Canning Jar: Wide-mouth canning jars work the best, especially for slices.

How to Serve Pickled Tomatoes

Pickled green tomatoes are also a great way to preserve an over-abundant tomato harvest because they can be used in various ways. Use them just as you would use ordinary cucumber pickles. Here are a few suggestions:

• As they are!
• Fried!
• As a topping on burgers
• Sandwiches
• Salad Dressings
• Potato Salad

This is one of my favorite green tomato recipes, and it will quickly become yours, too! How will you eat pickled tomatoes? We’d love to hear from you. Comment below and let us know!